How does prescription drug insurance differ from prescription discount cards?

October 19, 2023
4-minute read

HealthMarkets helps you differentiate between these 2 types of prescription payment options.

Next time you visit the pharmacy counter, you may spot a sign advertising prescription discount cards. Those cards, which are usually free, promise big savings on drug costs.

But before you get your prescription discount card and start using it, learn how it compares to prescription drug insurance. Using both wisely may help you reduce your prescription costs. Here’s what to know.

Why you may need help with prescription drug costs

Almost a quarter of Americans take 3 or more prescription drugs, and more than 70% of doctor visits involve getting some kind of medication. While many prescription drugs are affordable, there are some that are very, very expensive, according to insurance brokerbrokerA trained insurance professional who can help you enroll in a health insurance plan.
Read more »
 Matthew Claassen. He’s CEO of Medigap Seminars Insurance Agency in Palm City, Florida.

Where to get prescription drug insurance

Even though prescription drugs are an important part of modern medicine, health insurance doesn’t necessarily cover them. Here are some of the different situations that might come up involving your prescription drug coverage:

A licensed insurance agent can help you find plans that have prescription drug coverage. Call 1-877-237-5868 to discuss available plans, or browse your options online today.

How prescription drug coverage works

Each drug plan has a list of drugs (aka a formularyformularyA list of prescription drugs covered by a plan offering prescription drug benefits.
Read more »
) that shows all the medications it covers. Those medications are typically grouped into 3 or more tierstiersTiers are how drugs on a formulary are organized. Your cost depends on which drug tier your drug is in.
Read more »
 based on how much you’ll pay at the pharmacy counter. For example, a tiertierTiers are how drugs on a formulary are organized. Your cost depends on which drug tier your drug is in.
Read more »
 1 generic drug might have a $5 copaycopayFixed amount you pay for a covered health care service.
Read more »
, a tier 3 preferred brand-name drug might have a $25 copay, and a tier 5 specialty drug might have 20% coinsurancecoinsurancePercentage of costs of a covered health care service you pay after your deductible.
Read more »
. (That means you’ll pay 20% of the total cost of the drug.)

Since everyone is taking different medications, the plan that is best for you might not be as good for your spouse or best friend.

“The right plan will depend on the specific medications that you take. It will depend on whether the drug is covered under the formulary. It will depend on the dosage that you take. And it will depend on the pharmacy where you’d like to get the medication,” says Ari Parker. He’s the author of It’s Not That Complicated: The Three Medicare Decisions to Protect Your Health & Money and cofounder of Chapter, which offers free Medicare resources to older adults.

How prescription discount cards work

It’s worth knowing that prescription discount cards, such as Optum Perks, aren’t a form of insurance. Instead, they offer discounts on certain drugs at pharmacies that accept the cards. You can search for a drug by name on the discount card’s app or website to find the out-of-pocket costout-of-pocket costYour expenses for medical care that aren't reimbursed by insurance.
Read more »
 at participating pharmacies near you. (Keep in mind that, depending on the drug, there may be a wide variety of prices.)

“Like any discount plan, they can offer good coverage because they have large buying power,” Claassen says. Also, pharmacies are often willing to receive less money for each prescription just to get you in the store, much like grocery stores offering great prices on weekly specials.

When you pay for a prescription using a discount card, what you spend doesn’t apply to your insurance’s deductibledeductibleThe amount you pay for covered health care services before your insurance pays.
Read more »
 or your maximum out-of-pocket amount. (The maximum out-of-pocket is the most you’d have to pay for covered services in a plan yearplan yearA year of benefits coverage under an individual health insurance plan.
Read more »
.) While this is probably only a concern with expensive medications, you’ll still want to keep it in mind when you’re deciding the most cost-effective way to pay.

Call a licensed insurance agent at 1-877-237-5868 to talk about an Optum Perks discount card today.

When to choose which drug discount card

So, how should you pay for your next prescription? “It depends on the medication and where you intend to fill it,” Parker says. Claassen recommends that you first compare prices, as well as read the fine print, when you sign up for a prescription discount card.

Can you get by with just a prescription discount card?

Even if every prescription you take is cheaper with a prescription discount card, Parker says you’ll still want to have prescription drug coverage. There’s always a chance that you’ll unexpectedly need a drug that is much more expensive when using a discount card — if it’s included at all.

What’s more, if you’re a Medicare member and don’t sign up for drug coverage when you become eligible, you’ll have to pay a late enrollmentenrollmentThe process by which an eligible person becomes a member of an insurance plan.
Read more »
 penalty. This penalty equals 1% of the “national base beneficiary premiumpremiumThe amount you pay for your health insurance every month.
Read more »
,” or $34.70 in 2024, for each month you skip coverage. And it never goes away.

“Even for people who are not taking any medications, I recommend a Part D plan. Many plans only cost 2 to 3 cups of coffee per month,” he says. “Why take the chance that you won’t have a medication added during the year?”

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Therapeutic Drug Use.” February 23, 2023. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/drug-use-therapeutic.htm

Congressional Budget Office. “Reduce Medicare Advantage Benefits.” December 7, 2022. Retrieved from https://www.cbo.gov/budget-options/58626

Healthcare.gov. “What Marketplace Health Insurance Plans Cover.” Retrieved from https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/what-marketplace-plans-cover/ Accessed August 17, 2023

Internal Revenue Service. “Affordable Care Act Tax Provisions for Small Employers.” Retrieved from https://www.irs.gov/affordable-care-act/employers/affordable-care-act-tax-provisions-for-small-employers Accessed August 17, 2023

Medicare.gov. “Part D late enrollment penalty.” Retrieved from https://www.medicare.gov/drug-coverage-part-d/costs-for-medicare-drug-coverage/part-d-late-enrollment-penalty Accessed August 17, 2023

Medicaid.gov. “Prescription Drugs.” Retrieved from https://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid/prescription-drugs/index.html Accessed August 17, 2023

Health Insurance
Prescriptions
Query card

Uninsured? We can help.